Skip to main content

Christian Leader and the Leadership Development Paradox.

 

Here is some food for thought.

 

Why is it that when it comes to leadership development, we give training to those leaders who have the most experience, or to the hi flyers and performers  in our congregations and church organisations ? By their very character and performance these people are natural leaders and need this training the least.

 I want to spend a few moments talking about The Leadership Development Paradox.

 Many church leaders choose only the best to lead their teams, while this is great, what about the rest?

As Church Leaders we make assumptions about people all the time. It is how we evaluate them, nurture and train them. It is part of what we do.

Here are some assumptions that we make when developing leaders: 

 1. Success is always the result of Effort. People succeed because they have a strong work ethic and therefore by this thinking people who don't succeed do not work hard.

Here's the thing. Sometimes rather than give the leadership development training to those that always succeed, why not offer it to everybody. It may just be the thing that helps 'the rest' to step up.

 

2. Past and Present Performance will always Predict future Performance. It is natural to always want to award those that succeed.

 

The problem here is that the hi flyer and high performer is successful at the level they are now, but may not perform to the high standards and complexity needed in another role. Rather there is a need to look at a person's attributes other than their enthusiasm and passion for what they do. A better indicator would be to look to a person's intellectual aptitude and their ability to learn new things.

 

3. Only Motivated leaders benefit from leadership development training. Only those deemed ready for training are selected.

 

In other words those that would benefit the most out of Leadership Training, those with the greatest need are often not chosen. One way of including 'the rest' and not just the best, is to choose both types of people.

 

Results based training has seen that those who were the best and ready in the eyes of their leaders for leadership development training saw only moderate growth. But those who were in need of training saw performance increase by nearly two thirds.

 

What can we learn from this?

 

Churches can succeed develop and grow when they not only promote the enthusiastic and passionate high performers but those who would otherwise be considered 'the average rest'

 

By broadening your leadership development training to include everyone, you protect yourselves against future resignations and those who will leave you to go to what they think is a greener pasture.

 

Food for thought?



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The myth of Ministry Leadership.

The myth that all leaders are leaders. Not everyone who leads in church is a leader. I think it is wrong, for Church leaders to believe that those they train up to take various ministry leadership positions, are in fact leaders in their own right. They are not. At best I would categorise these people- that many churches call 'ministry leaders' as ministry managers.                 "At one level there is nothing wrong with title inflation; it is a cheap way of recognising people who work hard and make serious contributions" Jo Owen. I am of the opinion that this title inflation undervalues both the leader and the ' ministry manager' and can often bring about confusion and mismatched expectations. Many churches have ministry training evenings for their volunteers. Many use the reason for this training is "to make a person a better leader," when in fact the only thing actually happening is that th...
Post a Comment
Read more

The 1970's Christian Coffee Shop

I remember as a new Christian being invited into a Christian Coffee shop in the town where I grew up. It was clean and tidy, the table tops were all brightly painted in different colours,  but mainly yellow and scattered on top were a random selection of Christian tracts. Fish symbols and Christian posters proclaiming that there was but 'One Way' to heaven were everywhere. The music playing out of the stereo was The Bill Gather Trio or Dolly Parton singing Gospel. The crockery, was a mixed assortment of coffee mugs, donated by keen supporters of this outreach to the unsaved sinners and ungodly people living in the city. The coffee was a local brand heavily mixed with chicory. In all the years the Coffee Shop operated, I never saw a non-Christian go in and I never heard of a person coming to faith through having coffee there. I never really understood its purpose. Fast forward to today, when I was asked recently, to advise on helping a local community church open a c...
Post a Comment
Read more

Playing well with others.

Today's rambling. Looking over some of my old school reports the other day and was amused at how some of the comments, that teachers made about me have shaped my life and in many respects made me who I am today. One teacher wrote that I didn’t play well with others, I was 5 at the time maybe I had an excuse. Another teacher in my high school years, the wood working teacher or wood shop teacher for my American friends wrote; “If you value your life you will keep him away from power tools and other dangerous equipment. I can’t remember why he wrote this, obviously I did something that made him fear for his life. Today as an adult I have to say that I don’t do well in committees, for most of my life I have been self- employed. I have steadfastly stayed away from power tools and other wood working equipment, basically anything that can cut something off and is a danger to life and limb. Over the last 10 years I have been looking at and teaching about Emotional Intelligence ...
Post a Comment
Read more